I apologize for the inconvenience, I checked Toganash stream and saw what happened on 143 turn, which is indeed a violation of rules as blue player did not defeat guard, nor visit +1def again. I award tech win to Toganash.
As far as I knew, the party was saved before this incident happened, and Sector somehow forgot to mention this to me when describing the controversial situation. @Sector: Next time please submit the whole story, or provide stream evidence, because this led me to make a false decision, which I am not comfortable with.